Text Box: Where Do We End Our Probe on Root Cause Analysis?
Text Box: BOSS: Hey John, can you close the valve,
JOHN:  Which valve, BOSS ?

 

By Rolly Angeles

 

One of the biggest confusion in an attempt to perform a thorough Root Cause Analysis is understanding how deep should we pursue our analysis or simply stated, where do we stop our investigation in performing a Root Cause Analysis? Going to deep will lead us to the bible,  Timothy 6:10, For the love of money is a root of all evil and going to shallow will allow the problem to recur again and again.

 

Although a lot of analytical tools are currently being used by industries in the market today.  Are they really meant to uncover the root cause or simply what we termed as the physical cause of the problem only.  One industry found out that John Doe  was responsible for closing the valve that wrecked one of the turbines.  John Doe was sentenced to be suspended from work for 1 month without pay.  The lawyers and managers are happy that the culprit was finally condemned.  A year later, the same problem occurred and this time by a man named JOHNNY THORR, and he quote, I just use to sweep dirt around here but the supervisor instructed me to close the valve and I don’t know what valve so I close them all.  The question being raised here is John Doe and Johnny Thorr  the Root Cause of the problem? Are we certain if John Doe is punished, the problem will be gone for good?

 

Before we begin any further with our analysis, we need to ask ourselves in the first place, why do we need to perform a Root Cause Analysis?

 

Do we simply do it to comply with customer’s requirements such as manufacturing plants? Do we perform a Root Cause Analysis because our management wants to know what happened?  Do we need to perform a Root Cause Analysis because we want to know what simply caused the problem? The reason for asking your industry the reason to perform a Root Cause Analysis so that we can perform the analysis with the right reasons, and there is no better reason I can think of than learning from the failure itself.   We need to learn from the things that go wrong.

 

Again, do we learn from the failure when we discipline someone, or we just expand the gap between our people and us.  I recall a couple of years back when I was teaching Root Cause Failure Analysis for two days in one plant when after the end of the first day, one of the participants approached me and said, Sir, I’m afraid, I won’t be able to attend the 2nd part of your training tomorrow and when I asked why? The person said that he will be serving his suspension starting tomorrow for a weeks duration.  My curiosity aroused me so I asked the person which was a maintenance technician what happen and he told me that the operator committed an error and both of us will have to serve our suspension tomorrow. I asked why was he included if it was the operator who committed the mistake and he said that it was  the procedure management wants.  And the worst part is that their names and mistakes had been published detailing their mistake committed for everyone to see.  VERY HUMILIATING INDEED! By the way, this maintenance technician had already been in that industry for 12 years and it was his first taste of discipline in the number of years he worked for in that industry.

 

HUMAN CAUSE IN ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS

 

Root Cause Analysis believes that all failures are caused by humans but all humans are prone to commit a mistake and errors Either someone did the wrong job or simply did the job wrong.  People commit slips and lapses. Believe me when I tell you that even with the best procedures in town, people are likely to commit an error.

 

December 12, 2002 : A small plane belonging to Philippine Air Force crashed into a plant run by IBIDEN Philippines killing one person and injuring eight people.

 

A person died in the hospital since he was given the wrong blood, investigation indicates that the person who died switch bed with another person since he wanted to be near a window.  The nurse thought that this was the person that needs to have a blood transfusion.

 

People commit errors and errors can be classified as slips and lapses.  Slip is when somebody does something incorrectly such as an electrician rewinds a motor incorrectly that it run backwards. A lapse is trying to miss out  a step  in a key sequence of events such as leaving a tool behind after an extensive and exhaustive Preventive Maintenance in an equipment.  Both are Human Errors and both are not intentional in the first place. A lot of factors can be attributed as to cause these kinds of errors which may include fatigue, pressure, environment, inattention to details, just to name a few.

 

One thing we must understand is that most human error are not necessarily the fault of the person who actually committed the mistake.  What is important is that we need to understand  that either the error was caused by external circumstances far  beyond our control or from flawed rules and systems that needs to be changed.  We also need to understand the reason why the error was committed in the first place so we can learn from them. In fact,  are we convince that if we were on the shoes of the person who committed the error, will we do it differently?  But the most important lesson to asks is, do we really learn from the failure itself by blaming and punishing people?

 

LATENT CAUSE IN ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS

 

Underneath every Human Cause lies a deeper cause which is called the Latent Cause.  These are concealed and hidden causes that eventually cause the human error to be committed. The only way to address these Latent Causes is to expose them and we can only expose them if we truly understand what it is all about.  Latent Cause Analysis is not just about system flaws and procedures that eventually led a person to commit the mistake. It is not just about organizational management weaknesses.  It is not all about flawed management decisions but rather Latent Causes means understanding that we ourselves are also part of the problem.  People create system, people make decisions and if the decision or system is flawed  then a human error is most likely to occur without a doubt.

 

Learning from the things that go wrong is not as easy as we think it is.  The only way to learn from  the things that go wrong is if we can see ourselves in the mirror and admit the fact that we are all part of the problem.  Collectively, we all have our share that eventually caused a person to commit a mistake.  The sad thing about this is when this happens we isolate the person who commit the mistake and put all fingers and blame it on him because we always wanted a fall guy.

 

John 8:2—11 And the scribes and Pharisees brought unto Him a woman taken in adultery; and when they had set her in the midst, They say unto him, Master, this woman was taken in adultery, in the very act. Now Moses in the law commanded us, that such should be stoned: but what sayest Thou?" "This they said, tempting him, that they might have to accuse him." "But Jesus stooped down, and with his finger wrote on the ground, as though he heard them not. So when they continued asking him, he lifted up himself, and said unto them, he that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her.

 

Before we can understand Latency we need to ask ourselves the following:

- What is it about the way we are that contributes to our problems?

- What is it about the way I am that contributes to our problems?

 

If we are part of the problem, then we must be responsible in being part of the solution also.  Engineers, technical people, maintenance can easily arrived at the physical cause of the problem.  If some mechanical component such as a bearing failed, these people can dig up evidence that will eventually lead to its physical cause, but digging deeper into the latent cause, I strongly recommend a third party, an independent person and unbiased one, unless you can carry out the probe yourself.

 

Example of Physical Cause: Evidence on the bearing’s raceway shows fatigue and spalling, and after an investigation, the team found out that misalignment of the motor and pump seems to be the physical cause of the problem.

 

Example of Human Cause: After studying the evidences that lead to this misalignment problem, the team found out that the person performing the alignment do not posses the skills and do not have the tools to perform such practices.  He was only using his eye sight.

 

Probe on Latency:  Investigation shows that there was no instrument (Laser Alignment) and no training at all as to why these equipment needs to be aligned.  And when we probe on with the Latent Causes, we understand that each of us are part of the problem.

 

Training Department: After this incident occurred we at training department realized that a course on misalignment should be provided for our maintenance people to understand.

 

Maintenance Department: It is normal for management to budget and reduce operating cost, but this instrument is what we need to justified in order to improve our equipment uptime. We requisition this instrument a year ago but it was denied by Management.  I believe we can justify this instrument if we really want to by performing  a cost study in the first place and presenting an ROI to management, I’m damn sure that it won’t be denied.

 

Purchasing Department: We always adhere to management to cut cost and to the extent that we change vendors on parts which are more cheaper, I think part of our fault is not to consult this with our technical people for evaluation purposes.

 

Top Management: We should have provided the budget for training and instrument in the first place, I learn to realize after this severe downtime that this instrument maintenance is asking is not a nice to have but a must have after all.

 

And again, tell me if we are all part of the problem or is the person who perform the misalignment be condemned “ALONE” in the first place?  Let us all be in the shoes of this person who made the mistake and ask ourselves are we certain that we have done it differently?

 

Latency is not about system causes but rather understanding how we people in a way contribute to the problem since we taught that we are serving in the best interest of the company.  I consider latency to be a higher form of human cause. Again, exposing these Latent Causes is the only way to understand a true and meaningful Root Cause Analysis.  Hence, to answer the question, where do we end our probe on Root Cause Analysis only when we reach the Latent Cause of the problem.

 

Text Box:

Maintenance has one trait “humility”, hence, in all we do, let us  keep our heads down and remain unknown for that is who we really are.

 

Text Box: To Unsubscribe:

RSA Reliability and Maintenance Consultancy Firm values the privacy of your email.  Should you wish to unsubscribe or do not want to receive any more email or messages from us kindly send me a blank email with unsubscribe on the subject and we will remove you from our mailing lists.  Click here to Unsubscribe!

 

Text Box: REFLECTIONS ON RELIABILITY:
rsa

RELIABILITY & MAINTENANCE CONSULTANCY FIRM

 

Where Serving Maintenance Mankind Worldwide

Oval:

RSA

Text Box: RSA Reliability & Maintenance Newsletter

Issue No. 9: January 2008

 

Text Box: RSA Books on Reliability and Maintenance:
Text Box: Text Box: We’re Serving Maintenance Mankind Worldwide
Text Box: RSA Reliability 2019 All Rights Reserved

Welcome to your Reliability Monthly Newsletter for the month of January 2008.  You are receiving this email because at some point in time and for reasons that you opted to be included in our Newsletter mailing list from our web at www.rsareliability.com

 

RSA Reliability Newsletter will be sent out once a month and provide you with quality articles and resources on our most common link which is reliability and maintenance, as well as regular updates on our articles.  I would like to personally invite you to visit our new website regularly and check out updates on our articles and training courses.

 

Finally should you be interested to contribute to our articles section or share any feedback, I encourage you to email me Click here to email me.  If for any reason you wish to unsubscribe from our newsletter, kindly send my a blank email with unsubscribe as the heading and we shall remove you from our mailing lists.  Once again I hope that you enjoy reading our Reliability Newsletter.

 

 

Price $ 69.99 USD

 

WCM Book Specs:

Total Pages: 314

Available in Kindle, Paperback

and Hardbound

Total Chapters: 15

Released: November 2009

Foreword Message: Robert Nelms

 

MRR Book Specs:

Total Pages: 372

Available in Kindle, Paperback

and Hardbound

Total Chapters: 12

Released: April 2016

Foreword Message: Peter Todd

 

Price $ 73.99 USD

 

OAM Book Specs:

Total Pages: 411

Available in Kindle, Paperback

and Hardbound

Total Chapters: 12

Released: September 2018

 

Price $ 74.99 USD

 

If you are interested in any of my reliability and maintenance books you can click this link on amazon where you can purchase them directly. Just click this link.

 

www.amazon.com

 

 

 

Text Box: Text Box: Greatest Band on the planet celebrating their 54 years together
Text Box: TRAINING FEEDBACK and TESTIMONIES
Text Box: RSA Reliability Books
(Reserve your Copy Now)
Text Box: RSA 2019 Training
 Schedule
Text Box: RSA FORUM
( Discussion Board)

Text Box: RSA RELIABILITY 2019
UPDATES
rsa updates

RSA Reliability Newsletter will be provided once a month to our valued RSA Reliability Sub-scribers. It provides highlights as well as issues, solution and lessons regarding our most common interest w/c is all about  improving the reliability of our equipment. This is a paid subscription.  A two time payment  of 24.99 USD will be required which will be billed for two consecutive months in order for you to access my newsletter vault.  You can pay by clicking on this link.

 

Just completed my third book on Reliability - A Shared Responsibility for Operators and Maintenance which is a sequel to my first two books World Class Maintenance Management - The 12 Disciplines and, Maintenance -Roadmap to Reliability are now available at www.amazon.com.  WCM book speaks about the 12 Disciplines on Maintenance and MRR book is about a sequel to WCM book.  These not only cover about the technical jargon on reliability and maintenance, it is a book that makes every single maintenance proud that they belong to the maintenance function.  If you have been living through the day to day pressures of doing maintenance then this is your story.  If you are interested in this book, send me an email.  Click Here!

 

 Registration at this forum is done through administration only. Should you be interested to join send me an email and we will provide you with a user ID and password. Visit my discussion board and forum.  Click Here!

 

 Share what you know. Come and join our RSA Maintenance Forum.    Send me an email

 

 If your industry is interested to join and participate in any of our upcoming public training and Master Class for this calendar year 2019, you  may send us an email or simply fill out the registration form provided on our schedule site.  You may Click here to visit our schedule training for 2019 Schedule.

 

 This portion is dedicated to the greatest band of all times “The Rolling Stones, which started in 1962 and still together. What made them stick together after simply five decades (fifty four years) of music I simply can’t say,  As Keith Richards said in his book “Life. if I can excite Mick then Mick can excite the world. Last 2012 they started celebrating their fifty years of Rock and Rolling as a band.

 

We are very much flattered and humbled by your feedback and testimonies.  Your messages are the main reason for allowing us to stay in this business.  With all humility we say thank you and rest assure that we are continuously improving.  Without your support in our training there won’t be us.  Read More!

 

 Gallery: All 2019 training photos and pictures onwards will also be uploaded in my Facebook.

 RSA Newsletter Vault: This is a two  time paid newsletter subscription.  If you are interested to subscribe to my newsletter vault, kindly send me an email if you want to subscribe.

 2019 Training Schedule: If you are interested to attend in any of our public workshop and master class for 2019.  Send us an email or register online.

 RSA Books: If you’re interested to buy the book on World Class Maintenance - The 12 Disciplines,  Maintenance Roadmap to Reliability or my recent book which is Reliability A Shared Responsibility for Operators and Maintenance send me an email to reserve.  All my books are written in sequel.  This is a book w/c is highly recommended for every maintenance working in industries. Limited copies.

 In-house Training: Should your industry be interested for any of the courses we provide for in-house trainings kindly send us an email and we will provide you with a proposal.  We are now accepting reservations for in-house training for both local and international countries.  Contact us.

 

RSA UpdatesText Box: RSA Newsletter Vault
(One Time Paid Subscription)
rsabutton
buttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbuttonbutton

COURSES

 

PROFILE

 

GALLERY